Cerenovus
The Cerenovus chooses a player & a character. Put the Cerenovus to sleep. Wake the target. Show the THIS CHARACTER SELECTED YOU token, the Cerenovus token, then the madness-character token.
Librarian
Show the Outsider character token. Point to both the OUTSIDER and WRONG players.
Chef
Give a finger signal.
Empath
Give a finger signal.
Fortune Teller
The Fortune Teller chooses 2 players. Nod if either is the Demon (or the RED HERRING).